Saturday, March 10, 2018

Metropolitan Opera – Puccini’s Madama Butterfly. March 8, 2018.


Metropolitan Opera at Lincoln Center.  Orchestra (Seat CC32, $25).

Story.  See previous post.

Conductor – Marco Armiliato.  Pinkerton – Roberto Aronica, Goro – Tony Stevenson, Suzuki – Maria Zifchak, Sharpless – Roberto Frontali, Cio-Cio-San – Ermonela Jaho.


Projection on curtain at the end of the opera.

The “previous post” referenced above is from 2006, a good 12 years ago.  A search of my blog shows my first entry referenced having seen this opera before, and Anne and I recall seeing only the one by New York City Opera.  One reason for the story being so familiar has to be its simplicity, and perhaps also its lasting impression on the audience.  I remember listening to WQXR a couple of weeks ago.  The broadcasters must have seen or heard this multiple times, yet their voices broke when they described the synopsis of Act III.

The set is easy to describe, yet the sceneries – such as they are – are captivating.  What we have is an empty stage with steps in the back that also turn into a slope.  Different screens are moved around to denote rooms and doors, and on a couple of occasions people would disappear behind them in a bit of magic.  Most (or all) of the time they are moved by people in dark clothing; the idea is for the audience to ignore them, although that is a bit difficult to do.  Above the stage is a huge reflective panel that provides another view of the stage which is lit with a lighting system that moves.  Strings of reflective pieces are used to denote stars and also act as a curtain.

So in the hands of a clever set designer simplicity works.  Today's set worked much better than what we saw in Semiramide.

The other WQXR bit I remember is when this set first came out (it was the 2006-07 season) their was a description of these puppets.  I thought marionettes, but I was wrong. Turns out these are large articulated “objects” (for lack of a better term) moved around by three people in dark clothing.  Both Anne and I didn’t think it worked, especially with Butterfly’s child.  The head of the child is close to being grotesque – Chucky, anyone?  Most of the time it was difficult to ignore the puppeteers, I pity the one who had to bend down all the time to move the child’s feet.  I did like the sequence when the child slept in Butterfly’s lap and the three puppeteers knelt behind him; it was surprisingly touching.  The other puppet was used in the ballet scene in Act III.  It was dressed as Cio-cio-san.

The singing was uniformly excellent.  I especially like how “un bel di vedremo” was sung.  Our seats were in the back of the auditorium, so it was only when I used binoculars that I found Jaho unconvincing as a teenager (perhaps no mature singer can get away with this.)  However, her singing carried the show, from “ethereal” to “resigned” (among the adjectives used in the Playbill.)

Curtain call.  This is basically the set.

One surprise was how “oriental” a lot of the music sounded.  Equally surprising was the two tunes most people know about (“humming chorus” being the other one) didn’t sound that oriental.

The gentleman sitting in front had Italian on the screen, and the bird “robin” is “pettirosso” (red-breasted bird.”  Interesting only because at one point I learned some Italian so I could understand these operas better.

I couldn’t find a review in the New York Times, but the writer of the Operawire review loved Jaho.

There was a winter storm that swept through the area the day before (Wednesday) and we were a bit worried what the street conditions would be like.  Nonetheless we decided to drive in.  The streets were clear, and we had no problems with finding parking.  Also, attendance was quite good.

Dinner was at Europan.  Traffic home was unexpected busy on our way home.

No comments: