Avery Fisher
Hall at Lincoln Center, Orchestra (Seat V16, $40).
Pre-Concert
Recital – Orion Weiss, Piano.
Klavierstucke,
Op. 118 (1893) by Brahms (1833-1897).
Program
Chaconne in D
minor for piano left hand (1720/1877) by Bach (1685-1750) (trans.Brahms).
Piano Concerto
No. 20 in D minor, K.466 (1785) by Mozart (1756-1791).
Symphony No. 4
in E minor (1884-85) by Brahms.
Today’s program
is more properly titled “Mostly Brahms.”
The entire program, including the pre-concert, lasted about 110
minutes. Brahms was involved with every
single work, while Mozart’s own contribution was less than 30 minutes. In case one’s is wondering, the first
movement cadenza in the Mozart concerto was by Brahms. The annotator (Paul Schiavo) pointed out
other rationale for how the program hangs together, such as the frequent use of
minor keys, or how the pieces progress from one for a solo piano to
piano/orchestra and finally for a full orchestra.
We heard the
Chaconne piece played by Leon Fleisher in Toronto a few years back. If I were to go back to my notes, I probably
would have said something like “transcriptions from one instrument to another
usually doesn’t usually work well as different instruments have different
characteristics.” Going back to my
notes, I said “… it didn’t sound as good or natural compared to being played on
a violin.” If I were to make a
comparison, I thought it worked much better today as the different lines were
very well delineated. Of course the
percussive nature of the piano made some passages sound a bit disjoint. It was overall quite enjoyable.
Of the many
concertos Mozart wrote (close to thirty) only two are in the minor key. Of course one can make the minor key sound
sunny, and there are quite a few passages in this concerto that sounded that
way. Overall, though, it is more on the
moody side, beginning with the orchestral statement at the start.
This orchestra
introduction is my first encounter with the MMFO this season. I went in with a rooting for them attitude,
but was frankly disappointed. Tentative,
imprecise, uninspired were some of the adjectives that came to mind. During the early moments when the pianist was
having an ongoing dialog with the orchestra, I actually felt bad for the
pianist as he tried to take the performance to a higher level.
The good news is
that eventually he did. Denk put in a
well-structured and dynamic presentation.
Aided by the Program Notes, I rode along the ups and downs expressed by
the composer and eventually let the music carry me along.
Denk played an
encore that I would have guessed Bach as the lines were clear and the harmony
traditional, except for the many rubatos.
Anne overheard someone saying it might have been composed by Faure. Let’s just say one of us is very off. In any case, I like Denk’s playing. The Playbill writeup on him said he had
performed with the New York Philharmonic before, but this was the first time I
heard/heard of him.
I am quite
familiar with the Brahms symphony, so have in my mind a “proper” way to deliver
it. Tonight I needed to make quite a bit
of adjustments, including how small the orchestra is for such a big hall, but
overall enjoyed it. I was surprised how
unfamiliar the fourth movement sounded, and attributed that to my always
falling asleep after three movements.
The pre-concert
was an intimate piece by Brahms (Intermezzo in A minor, Intermezzo in A major,
Ballade in G minor, Intermezzo in F minor, Romanze in F major, and Intermesso
in E-flat minor.) The appreciation of
the piece was greatly helped by the notes in the Program.
On the way home,
we put on the Mozart concerto, performed by Malcolm Bilson on period
instruments. It sounded downright sunny.
We spent most of
July in the Boston area. We left Boston
at around 10:30 am this morning and got to the Lincoln Center area around 4:30
pm, managing to find off-street free parking on a Friday afternoon. We had time for coffee and a simple dinner
before heading to the pre-concert. The
box office had some problem with locating my “will-call” ticket (misfiled, they
said,) but things got squared away eventually.
Attendance was quite good (third tier was closed off,) but I wonder how
many got discounted tickets like I did.
No comments:
Post a Comment