David Geffen Hall at Lincoln Center. Second Tier (Seat CC1, $81.40).
Program
Theme and Variations, Op. 42 (1953) by Korngold (1897-1957).
Concerto in E minor for Violin and Orchestra, Op. 64 (1844) by Mendelssohn (1809-47).
Straussiana (1953) by Korngold.
Der Rosenkavalier Suite (1909-10/1944) by R. Strauss (1864-1949).
For the past couple of weeks we heard radio ads about this concert (WQXR radio) multiple times, talking about NY Phil's concertmaster Frank Huang performing the Mendelssohn violin concerto. While I enjoy the concerto, it wasn't enough to make me want to go to this concert. We are staying in Hoboken most of this week, and the concert is on a Friday morning, so when reasonably price tickets became available, I decided to give it a try (more on that later).
The program is short; each half less than 35 minutes, and a bit confusing, for someone not steeped in knowledge of German composers who can't tell apart Richard Strauss and Johann Strauss.
Korngold, for some reason, is enjoying a revival of some sort. This was our third encounter with the composer this year; and I had only two encounters with his music per entries in this blog.
Theme and Variations is exactly what one would expect: theme and variations. Korngold made it a point to not disguise the theme, with the result that the music is easy to analyze - perhaps too easy. The coda as such has the theme best hidden, but still quite "catchable." The music is pleasant enough, but few people would make this an important factor in going to a specific concert. Indeed I have forgotten the theme, although I suspect I can still recognize it if I hear it the next few days.
Straussiana is based on Johann Strauss's three less-known pieces: Neue Pizzicato-Polka (from Furstin Ninetta), a Mazurka, and Bitte-Schon-Polka (Cagliostro in Wein). I am not a fan of Strauss's waltzes (especially the Blue Danube, which is way too long), and I suppose some pieces are not popular for a good reason, but was okay with sitting through a 6-minute piece. I mistakenly thought the bases were all waltzes - even though I read the Program Notes in advance - I was somewhat surprised at a section that wasn't in triple time. Turns out polkas (in Europe at least) are in duple meter).
When the Mendelssohn concerto began, I was amazed at how clean the piece sounded. Huang's violin sang out brilliantly against a rather large orchestra (perhaps 10 first violins), and the balance was great between the soloist and ensemble. Perhaps the best "compliment" would be my thinking "this is like a well-engineered recording." That balance was achieved throughout the piece, except for a few loud passages that I assume no soloist can stand out.
As with many popular pieces, I have in mind a "canonical" way these pieces should be performed. And Huang by-and-large followed it, except he took some rubato passages in a more pronounced way. Which was okay. Somewhat unexpected were the few (slight) intonation problems he had, and that kept me on the edge of my seat whenever he had to make substantial leaps in pitch; and there were quite a few of them.
It was an enjoyable performance. But not an inspired one. Perhaps this violin concerto can never get to the "inspired" level: one can be amazed at how it showcases the versatility of the instrument and the prowess of the soloist, but it is difficult to read a story behind it (a prime example of the latter is Sibelius). A final observation was that the orchestra was very much an equal partner today, a compliment to the conductor.
When it comes to Der Rosenkavalier, I have only two items in mind: the Presentation of the Rose theme and the Baron Ochs waltz. There are reasonably heavy doses of both in the suite, although I didn't catch an entire "rose" theme, and the Ochs waltz was repeated too many times. Otherwise the performances sounded mostly chaotic, surprisingly so after how clean the Mendelssohn sounded. Another surprise is that the arranger for this suite, with some music not in the original opera, remains unknown. Many believe it was done by Rodzinski for the New York Philharmonic, and Strauss was aware of it, and had no problem with it.
There is a storyline associated with the suite, but I wasn't following it.
This was Roberto Gonzalez-Monjas's New York Philharmonic debut, and I thought he came across very well. He is still an active violinist, and teaches at London's Guildhall School.
A few words about the tickets. The NY Phil website showed a price of $175 for seats in this section of the auditorium, I got two via StubHub for $162.80, with my credit card company reimbursing me $150. The tickets I got show a price of $38.50(!). I don't know how the original purchaser got such a reduction for the price (I personally consider 30% off list a great deal, but have snagged some for 50% off). The acoustics were quite good.
It's a short bus and subway ride to get to and from Lincoln Center from Hoboken, where we spend some of the time. Anne wanted to try the street food, so we had some before we returned.












