Symphony Hall, Boston, MA. First Balcony (Seat D27, $35.50).
Conclusion of the performance. Philippe Jordan holding the baton on the left. Next to him are the three soloist (soprano, bass, and tenor). The Chorus director is on the right. The second harpsichord can be seen on the right.
Program
The Creation (1798) by Haydn (1732-1809).
Artists
Louise Alder as Gabriel and Eve, soprano.
Bogdan Volkov as Uriel, tenor.
David Steffens as Raphael and Adam, bass-baritone.
Tanglewood Festival Chorus, Jean-Sebastien Vallee, conductor.
Anne and I were in Boston this weekend, and the oratorio "The Creation" was being performed by the BSO.
Anne and I both recall listening to this work on two prior occasions; she just remembered, I looked up entries in this blog. Once at the Yale auditorium (before my blogging days, and after Ellie started at Yale in 2001); the other time was Mostly Mozart at Avery Fisher Hall.
The "plot" of the composition is quite straightforward. Part I describes the first four days of the Genesis account of the creation (sun and moon); Part II is devoted to the creation of animals (living creatures) and humans; Part III gives us an initial account of Adam and Eve - no mention of the fall, though. The three soloists sing the role of the angels Gabriel, Uriel, and Raphael in Parts I and II, and Adam and Eve (and presumably Uriel?) in Part III. One woman voice from the chorus is added briefly to form a quartet.
Overall, it was a disappointment. Creation as described by cosmologists (think "big bang") can be excited and explosive, the biblical narrative is more subdued, but can be interesting. Since Haydn was a very religious man, one could also hope for a spiritually uplifting experience. None of that happened, not to me anyway. I found the experience straightforward, and the performance was the equivalent of someone reading the first few chapters of Genesis matter-of-factly.
Handel's Messiah was composed over 50 years prior, and one wonders if Haydn had that in mind when he composed this oratorio. I must have heard The Messiah 30 times, and will again later this year. As I said earlier, this was our third listen of Creation.
This concert was the last in a series of three, so I was somewhat surprised that the orchestra was not as precise as I expected (especially for the BSO). Now this program must have been set before the Nelsons "incident" (contract not renewed) was made public, but one wonders if this was also an audition for Jordan. He certainly has the star power (including conducting the Ring Cycle at the Met, and the withdrawal at Bayreuth), but this series couldn't have been the best he could deliver.
Jordan and others acknowledging the Chorus and its director. About 80 of them. If one zooms in one notices the number of empty seats for tonight's performance.
Interestingly, the couple of reviews I read on line have glowing reports of the performances, perhaps boosters of the Jordan candidacy? The writers at least acknowledged poor attendance.
A brief note on how I got these tickets. It started with my looking for a concert for the weekend. Plenty of tickets were available, many via Stubhub. As Stubhub charges exorbitant markups for tickets they sell, I waited to see if prices would drop as the concert date moved closer. For First Balcony seats they remained in the $120 range for a long time. I then got an email from BSO offering the best remaining seats for $25 each (yes, $25). So I bought two. The service charge was $20.50, still a great bargain for a BSO concert.
(Why StubHub? A credit card I have offers a $150 credit for StubHub credit every six months. In this case buying two would cost $240, with $150 offset by the credit, I will still pay $90. Both Anne and I get that credit, but then we have no control over whether we will sit together.)
Joe P's family and we had an early dinner at Pho Town 7 in Medford, Joe then dropped us off at and picked us up from Symphony Hall. It rained during the day, sometimes heavily; we were fortunate that we didn't get soaked.








